Decision guide

Shopify vs WooCommerce
A hosted platform or a store you assemble yourself.

This gets argued as a licence-fee question — Shopify charges monthly, WooCommerce is free — which is the least useful way to look at it. WooCommerce is free the way a puppy is free.

The honest framing

Start with the shape
of the problem.

This gets argued as a licence-fee question — Shopify charges monthly, WooCommerce is free — which is the least useful way to look at it. WooCommerce is free the way a puppy is free.

The real variable is who carries the operational load. On Shopify, hosting, PCI scope, checkout security and platform upgrades are somebody else’s problem, and you accept their constraints in exchange. On WooCommerce you own all of it, and with that ownership comes the freedom to do things Shopify will not let you do.

We build on both, and the recommendation usually turns on two questions: how unusual is your checkout, and who patches the server at eleven on a Friday night.

Shopify compared with WooCommerce across 8 criteria
Criterion	Shopify	WooCommerce	Edge
Real three-year cost	Predictable subscription plus transaction fees and app subscriptions. Rises with revenue but rarely surprises.	No licence, but hosting, security, backups, developer retainer and paid extensions add up — usually to more than teams project.	Shopify
Checkout control	Locked down unless you are on Plus. That constraint is also why the checkout converts and stays PCI-compliant.	Complete control. You can build any flow you like, including the ones that quietly lose money.	Line ball
Hosting and uptime	Managed, globally distributed, and not your problem during a traffic spike or a security advisory.	Yours. Peak-season capacity, patching and backups all need an owner with a pager.	Shopify
Content and SEO flexibility	Capable but opinionated: URL structure is largely fixed and blogging is basic.	WordPress underneath, so content modelling, taxonomy and URL control are as flexible as you need.	WooCommerce
Complex catalogues and pricing	Variant limits and B2B pricing rules get awkward without apps or a Plus plan.	Handles bespoke pricing, complex variants and unusual tax logic without fighting the platform.	WooCommerce
Extension risk	Reviewed app store, sandboxed apps. Sprawl slows the storefront but rarely breaks it.	Plugins execute in your stack. One abandoned plugin can be a security incident rather than a nuisance.	Shopify
PCI and compliance burden	Shopify carries the bulk of the scope. Your SAQ is materially simpler.	Scope depends on your setup, and a hosted payment field is the difference between manageable and painful.	Shopify
Portability	Data exports cleanly; theme and app logic does not. Leaving means rebuilding the front end.	Everything is yours — database, code, server. Migration is work, not a rescue mission.	WooCommerce

Choose shopify if

Your catalogue is conventional and your checkout does not need to be unusual
Nobody internally wants to own hosting, patching or peak-season capacity
You want to trade rather than to run infrastructure
Reliability during a campaign matters more than doing something bespoke at checkout
You are replatforming from something fragile and want the operational load to drop

Choose woocommerce if

Pricing, bundling or tax logic is genuinely unusual and central to the business
Content and search are a primary acquisition channel and you need full URL control
You already run WordPress well and have someone accountable for the stack
You need deep integration with systems Shopify apps do not reach
Owning the whole stack is a deliberate commercial decision, not a default

Our honest
recommendation.

For most merchants under a few million in revenue with a conventional catalogue, Shopify wins on total cost of ownership once you count the hours WooCommerce quietly consumes. The constraint that annoys developers is the same constraint that keeps the store trading while everyone is asleep.

WooCommerce earns its place when the business logic is genuinely unusual, when content and search drive acquisition, or when you already run WordPress competently and have a named owner for the stack. It is a good answer chosen deliberately and a bad one chosen to avoid a subscription.

The one combination we advise against is WooCommerce with no maintenance budget. An unpatched store with a dozen abandoned plugins is not a saving; it is an incident with a delay on it.

Follow-up questions

What teams ask next.

On licence fees, yes. On three-year total cost, usually not. Once hosting, backups, security patching, paid extensions and the developer time to keep it all working are counted, most mid-sized WooCommerce stores cost more to run than the equivalent Shopify plan — the difference is that the cost is distributed and therefore easier to under-count.

WooCommerce gives you more control — URL structure, taxonomy, content modelling, redirects — because WordPress sits underneath. Shopify is perfectly capable of ranking, but its fixed URL patterns and thin blogging tools are real constraints if content is a primary channel. For most stores the deciding factors are site speed and information architecture, both of which are achievable on either.

Yes, with a complete redirect map, a deliberate URL structure and reconciliation of every product, variant and customer record before cutover. The risk in a replatform is almost never the platform; it is the fortnight of preparation people skip.

It buys checkout extensibility, higher API limits and B2B features, and it is worth it when the checkout genuinely needs to differ or when wholesale is a real channel. It is not worth it as an upgrade in principle — we have seen more Plus plans bought than needed.

Other guidesAgency vs freelancer In-house vs outsourced development Custom vs WordPress React Native vs native Headless vs traditional CMS

Capabilities this decision touches

Websites & Commerce